Week 2: HighScope, Reggio…influences on GalaMundi

Mae b -

Hi everyone! This week, I went to the Speech and Debate State tournament in Phoenix and spent some more time with the kids at GalaMundi. Elsa sent me documents outlining the curriculums GalaMundi uses, called HighScope and Reggio Emilia. I’ll be explaining them in this post.

I’ll get to Reggio Emilia later. HighScope emphasizes the importance of “active” learning, allowing students to choose experiences, requiring them to reflect on their choices, and giving them hands-on learning. Intuitively, I know that young students develop better when they aren’t simply told what to think but rather allowed to explore, but it is nice to see that HighScope agrees. HighScope is founded on a series of comprehensive studies finding that learning is most effective when students take responsibility for themselves.

One of the things I’ve noticed Elsa and Yadira doing is constantly asking the students questions –“¿Qué es eso?” (“What is this?”)–and giving the students tasks or toys that are just a wee bit challenging for them. The one-and-a-half-year-olds are often given a narrow-mouth container to put necklaces into, an activity that requires them to build hand-eye coordination. The four-year-olds make letters out of little tiles. I noticed this as part of the HighScope curriculum, called “Adult Scaffolding.” From the curriculum, “Adult Scaffolding” is when “[a]dults support children’s current level of thinking and challenge them to advance to the next developmental stage through thoughtful interactions and questioning.” This is just one of the many strategies GalaMundi implements as recommended by HighScope.

Now, GalaMundi also uses the Reggio Emilia approach to teaching, which also emphasizes the child actively engaging with their environment to learn, rather than being talked at by a teacher. Reggio refers to the environment as a “third teacher,” explaining that teachers should set up the environment so that by engaging with it, students learn. GalaMundi does this by having containers and scoops to play with the wood chips outside, having blocks that can only be stacked in a certain way, and so many other things! HighScope suggests that teachers create different “zones” of the classroom with different materials: GalaMundi has an area with toy babies, an area with toy cars and a track, an area for playing with blocks, an area for reading, a toy kitchen, and a table with a daily game.

I went to Montessori from age three to age eight, and I remember lots of hands-on learning. What Elsa told me and what the information she sent me that compares Reggio to Montessori says is that while Montessori and Reggio share the same basic philosophy, Montessori is more structured. Each item has a specific use (I do remember having blocks specifically for stacking, beads for counting, and a set order that lessons were introduced – first this, then this, then this). Meanwhile, Reggio is more focused on allowing the student to do open-ended tasks, and items have many uses, open to children’s creativity. My gut tells me that unstructured discovery is probably better for younger kids, and introducing structure to learning is perhaps important as students get older. But I’m not sure!

I enjoyed reading these documents – they showed me that while GalaMundi feels very “go with the flow” and calm, there is actually a clear method and plan for the students’ development!

More Posts

Comments:

All viewpoints are welcome but profane, threatening, disrespectful, or harassing comments will not be tolerated and are subject to moderation up to, and including, full deletion.

    Corey Hartman
    Hi Mae! When you started describing the self-directed learning component, I also thought about Montessori. Your comment about unstructured versus structured learning and age is fascinating. If I remember correctly from my child's experience, Montessori was grouped based on development (which could be related to age, but sometimes not). How does the Reggio philosophy consider grouping? Is it by age, or is there also a component of level? Great post!
      mae_b
      Hi Ms. Hartman! Thanks for asking. The Reggio philosophy does group by age. In all four Montessori schools I know of, students are put in classrooms generally spanning three years of development. Two years of preschool + Kindergarten, 1st - 3rd grade, 4th-6th grade...things like that. Within that structure, kids are grouped by development into some lesson groups. For example, when I was in second grade, my teacher would pull me and a small group aside from our independent time doing our lessons to learn something new. Usually, this group would include mostly second-graders but perhaps a first or third grader sprinkled in. Reggio groups by age by recommending classrooms with only one year of students in it (so, only second-graders in a second-grade classroom). This is one of the biggest challenges at GalaMundi! During the pandemic, they had to shut down their daycare center, which had different classrooms for different ages of kids, and now they have kids ranging from 18 months to 6 years old in the same classroom! Elsa and Yadira tell me often that teaching such a wide age range of students is a challenge.
    samantha_g
    I had no idea about any of these curriculums, they are really interesting! You mentioned that HighScope suggested to create different "zones" for the children, do the different zones help the students engage in their environment better than not having any zones? Thanks!
      mae_b
      I think so, yes! The students go to the zone that is interesting to them at that time, and while there, it is easier to focus on what they are doing. Also, it helps kids learn for simply practical reasons: if the plastic letters were scattered everywhere, it would be impossible for one kid to fully engage with them because she could only find a few to work with at a time. Think about it like your house: it helps you have the materials you need and stay focused on your task when you have a space for art separate from a space for sleeping separate from a space for watching TV.
    Elsa OHearn
    Hello Again, Mae! I'm glad you're learning about our teaching methods at GalaMundi! You've really noticed how we work with the children. Yes, we use both HighScope and Reggio Emilia approaches. I love how these methods let children learn by doing and exploring. When we ask "¿Qué es eso?" or give the little ones those narrow containers for necklaces, we're helping them grow at their own pace. You noticed our classroom zones too! We set up different areas on purpose - the reading corner, block area, toy kitchen, and more. This helps children make choices and learn from their surroundings. As you said, the environment becomes another teacher. The difference you spotted between Reggio and Montessori is right. At GalaMundi, we're less structured than Montessori. We want kids to use materials in creative ways, not just one "correct" way. I'm happy you see that while our classroom feels relaxed, there's actually careful planning behind everything we do. The calm feeling comes from letting children follow their interests while we guide them. Thanks for sharing your thoughts! We look forward to you coming back.
      mae_b
      Thanks for commenting, Elsa! I'm starting to notice more and more carefully crafted activities that seem on face level simply fun, but actually serve a real educational purpose. It's fun!
    mason_t
    Hi Mae, I'm glad you mentioned Montessori, since I went there as a kid too. I also remember the set order in which lessons were introduced. I saw also that the "adult scaffolding" section of the HighScope curriculum also involves encouraging students to "the next developmental stage." Are these stages as clearly set as the Montessori curriculum, or is it more openly defined, as the GalaMundi approach seems to encourage? Thank you!
      mae_b
      Good question, Mason! I'm not completely sure how structured HighScope recommends being, but I think it's pretty open. HighScope was originally designed in the 1960's to help 123 African American children in Michigan succeed in school who were at serious risk of failing out. By its nature, HighScope is aimed at educating students who don't do well in traditional (often structured) schooling.
    maleea_m
    Having experienced both Montessori school and GalaMundi, which do you think you would choose for your own children? Your gut seems to lean toward GalaMundi, but in a real-life decision, would you still feel the same? Why?
      mae_b
      It really depends on the child and on the teacher. I'm not an expert, but in my opinion, good teachers help students flourish under any curriculum. The best teachers also don't teach solely within one curriculum - they are experienced enough to pull from multiple theories and real-life teaching experiences to create a student experience that really works. Also, the best teachers will understand the individual needs of their students and adapt - and that's where the "it depends on the kid" comes in. Reggio Emilia might be great for one kid and just okay for another. The same goes for Montessori. For my own kid, I would want them to be at a place that will help them learn (in whatever learning style they are suited to). Maybe they're suited to Montessori, maybe they're suited to GalaMundi, maybe something altogether different. In an ideal world, every school would adapt to the student rather than expecting students to go to a different school that matches them.
    eugene_j
    Hey Mae! It is wonderful that they focus on active learning. A part of me is dismayed that active learning isn't a focus for schools at older ages. Have you noticed if certain children prefer some zones in the classroom, or do they like trying out everything?
      mae_b
      The kids definitely have preferences! I'm thinking of one in particular that is glued inseparably to the toy babies. She loves them. So, yes, they have areas they like, but they also move around. I've seen every kid play everywhere. And since Reggio is such a free curriculum, they definitely mix different things around the classroom to their liking.

Leave a Reply to samantha_g Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *