Avni C's Senior Project Blog

Project Title: Analyzing the Evolution of Gendered Fitness Representations in Health Magazines 
BASIS Advisor: Ms. Ainslie
Internship Location: Remote
Onsite Mentor: N/A



Project Abstract

Fitness is undeniably essential to human well-being, and media representations of fitness have evolved significantly over the past few decades. Historically, women's picture of fitness has been linked primarily to weight loss and achieving a slim physique, whereas men’s fitness has been associated with solely muscle growth and physical strength. In recent years, however, there has been a cultural shift toward promoting strength and holistic health for women, influencing beauty standards and raising the question of how these changing ideals are reflected in mainstream health publications. Health magazines work to shape readers’ perceptions of fitness, influencing their goals and even their approaches and motivations to exercise. This project examines how fitness is presented differently to men and women in popular health magazines, specifically Men’s Health and Women’s Health. Through qualitative content analysis, I analyze how these publications frame different fitness goals, target specific body parts, and promote particular exercises. By comparing articles from two distinct time periods, I aim to identify shifts in messaging and potential gender discrepancies in fitness promotion. Understanding these patterns is necessary to recognize the role that the media plays in shaping public perceptions of fitness and self-image. The findings will shed light on whether modern fitness media continues to reinforce traditional gender norms or has evolved to portray a more equitable approach to health and exercise. This research adds to discussions on gender representation in media, and evolving fitness ideals in contemporary society. The findings will also highlight the progress—or lack thereof—toward more balanced and empowering fitness narratives for both men and women.

    My Posts:

  • Week 12: Conclusions

    It’s the last week of my senior research project, and I finally have some conclusions!   My study revealed significant gender-based patterns in fitness messaging across both Men’s Health and Women’s Health magazines from 2014 and 2024. These findings support the hypothesis; these gender-based discrepancies were more prominent in 2014, but have since somewhat converged... Read More

  • Week 11: Results

    And it’s the almost the final week!    I have finished my data analysis in its entirety and have come across some interesting trends and results.    The findings of this study reveal prominent patterns in gendered fitness messaging across Men’s Health and Women’s Health. In earlier issues, the 2014 issues of Women’s Health, there... Read More

  • Week 10: Pivoting

    Happy Week 10!    I nearly finished my ANOVA analysis when I realized I was gravely mistaken about what ANOVA truly answers. I’d been under the impression that ANOVA would analyze the proportions of different categories in my sample, but I was plainly wrong. It analyzes frequencies in terms of number of times. For instance,... Read More

  • Week 9: Continuation

    Happy Week 9!    This week’s been a steady trudge through actual data analysis; I’m about halfway through at this point. Overall, so far, I don’t want to draw any concrete conclusions, but it seems as though there are a few differences between Women’s health and Men’s Health in general, which is the data I’ve... Read More

  • Week 8: Choosing a Method of Analysis

    Happy Week 8!    This week, I spent my time learning more about how to perform a two-way ANOVA test, simply because it’s not a statistical test I’ve learned before. A two-way ANOVA test is used when comparing groups on two different categorical variables.    In my case, I’m measuring the effects of both gender... Read More

  • Week 7: Data Analysis

    It’s Week 7 already!   I’ll start with some good news: I’ve completed my data collection in full. However, because I have many categories, it’s a bit difficult to draw any preliminary conclusions at the moment. I may have been a bit too excited last week when I said I’d have all my analysis done... Read More

  • Week 6: Finding the Magazines

    We’ve made it to Week 6! I spent the past week looking for the magazines from 2014 in my local libraries - I went to Agave, Cholla, and Sunrise Mountain, all to no avail. It turns out that 2014 is just a bit too old for these libraries; the best I could find was one... Read More

  • Week 5: Data Collection + Methodology Adjustment

    It’s Week 5 and we’re about halfway through!   Similarly, I’m halfway through my data collection. 2024 is nearly completely done, so it’s about time to start thinking about how to get all of the 2014 magazines. Sometime in this next week, I’m planning to head over to my local library to check out their... Read More

  • Week 4: Data Collection Pt. 1

    Excited to be in week 4!   I’ve been steadily working at organizing all my data; there’s a LOT of it. As a side note, I never realized just how many ads there are in magazines; right after a couple pages of fitness material, I find myself flipping through a series of advertisements for new... Read More

  • Week 3: Pre-test

    Welcome to Week 3!   This week, I’ve been focusing solely on data collection using all issues published in Men’s Health in 2014 / 2024 and Women's Health in 2014 / 2024.    I created a sort of ‘pre-test’ (organizational scheme) from these aforementioned magazines using a random issue from 2013 and 2023, meaning 4... Read More

  • Week 2!

    Happy Week 2!   Due to the nature of my project, I’ve spent quite a bit of time this week immersing myself more in the world of fitness. I’ve read many fitness articles and talked to my friends who go to the gym often. It’s been fascinating - I've learned about exercise form, the role... Read More

  • Welcome! – An Introduction

    Hello everyone! My name is Avni Chidella, and I’m a senior at Basis Peoria. I’ll be honest here: I’ve never really been a huge fan of sports, or physical activity in general. That’s ironic, considering how active I was as a kid, to the point where I can barely believe it myself. I danced, swam,... Read More