Week 4: Digital v.s. Traditional

Emma K -

     Greetings readers! We are now starting to enter the illustration stage! First things first, as mentioned in my last blog, the color yellow is going to be the main visual motif throughout the story. It symbolizes the gift of gratitude that I received while growing up and pass down in the present!

     Today, I will be going through the pros and cons of both digital and traditional illustration, as well as the direction I decided to go with! 

     From the many picture books I’ve seen, the ones that caught my eye the most were the ones with rough, sketchy inking, but vibrant and meaningful coloring. “The Journey” by Aaron Becker was my biggest inspiration out of these books. 

     I wanted to choose the illustration method that would best allow me to emulate this kind of style, so I weighed my options carefully. 

     Traditional illustration was a strong candidate. First and foremost, I have many years of experience with various traditional mediums, such as acrylic, watercolor, pen, and charcoal. Since I am much more familiar with these materials, I would have an easier time with the rendering process and might be able to express the desired style better. However, it would still take a long time to finish, as I would have to reduce mistakes as much as possible, since my supplies (paints, bristol paper, etc.) are pretty limited. 

     On the other hand, I have less experience in digital illustration, but if there’s one thing I learned, it’s that the undo button becomes your greatest friend! This method, unlike traditional mediums, is much more forgiving, regardless of the “material” you use! This makes the illustration process much more efficient and allows me to experiment with different brushes and styles as much as I need without wasting materials. Through various texture brushes on Krita the drawing program I have been using I have access to many different brushes that mimic traditional mediums.

Krita!

     Moreover, the ability to scale the canvas up or down makes matching book printing formats later down the line way easier. Lastly, digital illustration doesn’t require as much space nor preparation to get the actual drawing process started, which makes my location a nearly irrelevant condition and gives me more flexibility!

     In conclusion, I decided to go with digital illustration, but I will definitely be going through a lot of experimentation, practice, and (especially) rough drafts before the final product! 

     Thank you for reading and I will see you next Wednesday!

More Posts

Comments:

All viewpoints are welcome but profane, threatening, disrespectful, or harassing comments will not be tolerated and are subject to moderation up to, and including, full deletion.

    nakyung_y
    Hey Emma! I never realized how many differences there really are to digital vs traditional art! Do you have any specific scenes or moments in your story that you want to use that will best showcase the yellow motif?
    emma_k
    Thank you Nakyung! In my draft, I actually include a yellow motif in every scene I plan to illustrate! I think the scene I absolutely want to do is when I show my desk in the present, and it's full of yellow mementos I've collected over the years! I think it really ties in the idea of how interwoven those experiences are with my identity!
    avaya_a
    I love the idea of using yellow as a symbol of gratitude! I can't wait to see how Krita helps you achieve the perfect traditional illustration look you're going for!
    ian_m
    Seems like a reasonable decision to make; physical art can get very expensive very quickly. Is there anything in this project that you feel that physical art could have emphasized well that digital art might struggle to express or need to compensate for?
    emma_k
    Thank you for the encouragement, Avaya!
    emma_k
    Hi Ian - definitely! I think the sense of certainty and boldness in my sketch lines might be lost a little in digital art, but it can't be helped, since that just comes from the experience and familiarity I've accumulated with the respective mediums.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *